How can I efficiently select several unique random numbers from 1 to 50, excluding x?

I have 2 numbers which are between 0 and 49. Let’s call them x and y. Now I want to get a couple of other numbers which are not x or y, but are also between 0 and 49 (I am using Objective C but this is more of a general theory question I think?).

Method I thought of is:

  • Crash when casting the result of arc4random() to Int
  • Non repeating random numbers in iphone?
  • How to get random numbers with the wrong generator
  • How to randomize letters correctly from an NSString
  • generating random numbers without consecutive repetition
  • generate reliable pseudorandom number
  •  int a;
     int b;
     int c;
     do {
      a = arc4random() % 49;
     } while ((a == x) || (a == y));
     do {
      b = arc4random() % 49;
     } while ((b == x) || (b == y) || (b == a));
     do {
      c = arc4random() % 49;
     } while ((c == x) || (c == y) || (c == a) || (c == b));

    But it seem kind of bad to me, I don’t know, I am just trying to learn to be a better programmer, what would be the most elegant way to do this for best practices?

    5 Solutions Collect From Internet About “How can I efficiently select several unique random numbers from 1 to 50, excluding x?”

    You can use something called the Fisher-Yates shuffle. It’s an efficient algorithm for producing a randomly ordered list of values from some set. You would first exclude N from the list of values from which to get random values, and then perform the shuffle.

    You should shuffle an array of numbers (of values [0, …, 49] in your case; you can also exclude your x and y from that array if you already know their values), then grab the first N values (however many you’re seeking) from the shuffled array. That way, all the numbers are randomly of that range, and not “seen before”.

    I’d do something more along the lines of:

    NSMutableSet * invalidNumbers = [NSMutableSet set];
    [invalidNumbers addObject:[NSNumber numberWithInt:x]];
    [invalidNumbers addObject:[NSNumber numberWithInt:y]];
    int nextRandom = -1;
    do {
      if (nextRandom >= 0) {
        [invalidNumbers addObject:[NSNumber numberWithInt:nextRandome]];
      nextRandom = arc4random() % 49;
    } while ([invalidNumbers containsObject:[NSNumber numberWithInt:nextRandom]]);

    You could add x, y and the new number to a data structure that you can use as a set and do something like (in pseudo-code; the set structure needs something like push to add values and in for checking membership):

    number_of_randoms = 2;
    for (i = 0; i<number_of_randoms; i++) {
      do {
        new_random = arc4random() % 49;
      } while !;

    So if objc has something appropriate, this is easy…[aha, it does, see Dave DeLong’s post].

    This algorithm makes sense if number_of_randoms is much less than 49; if they are comparable then you should one of the shuffle (aka permutation) ideas.

    First, make a set of valid numbers:

    // Create a set of all the possible numbers
    NSRange range = { 0, 50 };// Assuming you meant [0, 49], not [0, 49)
    NSMutableSet *numbers = [NSMutableSet set];
    for (NSUInteger i = range.location; i < range.length; i++) {
        NSNumber *number = [NSNumber numberWithInt:i];
        [numbers addObject:number];
    // Remove the numbers you already have
    NSNumber *x = [NSNumber numberWithInt:(arc4random() % range.length)];
    NSNumber *y = [NSNumber numberWithInt:(arc4random() % range.length)];
    NSSet *invalidNumbers = [NSSet setWithObjects:x, y, nil];
    [numbers minusSet:invalidNumbers];

    Then, if you don’t need the numbers to be guaranteed to be random, you could use -anyObject and -removeObject to pull out a couple of other numbers. If you do need them to be random, then follow LBushkin’s answer, but be careful not to accidentally implement Sattolo’s algorithm:

    // Shuffle the valid numbers
    NSArray *shuffledNumbers = [numbers allObjects];
    NSUInteger n = [shuffledNumbers count];
    while (n > 1) {
        NSUInteger j = arc4random() % n;
        [shuffledNumbers exchangeObjectAtIndex:j withObjectAtIndex:n];